Comparison · HVAC and furnace filters

Filterbuy Odor MERV 10 vs Filtrete MPR 1000 (18x18x1)

Two filters compared on the makers' own numbers.

Our verdict

In 18x18x1: pick the Filterbuy Odor MERV 10 if you want the least airflow resistance through the 18x18x1 for an older system. Pick the Filtrete MPR 1000 18x18x1 if allergies, pets or smoke are the priority for your 18x18x1 slot.

The central trade-off

Grade. In 18x18x1, Filtrete MPR 1000 (MERV 11) Air Filter is MERV 11; the 18x18x1 Filterbuy Odor & Allergy Defense MERV 10 Air Filter is MERV 10. The higher-grade 18x18x1 catches more fine particles (pollen, dander); a 18x18x1 filter at MERV 11 also adds airflow resistance, which matters most in 1-inch frames and older blowers.

Rating scales. The 18x18x1 Filterbuy Odor & Allergy Defense MERV 10 Air Filter lists MPR 1000. The 18x18x1 Filtrete MPR 1000 (MERV 11) Air Filter lists MPR 1000. MPR is 3M's own scale; MERV is the industry standard (ASHRAE 52.2).

The 18x18x1 size. Filterbuy Odor & Allergy Defense MERV 10 Air Filter: its own listing (actual 17.5 x 17.5 x 0.75 in). Filtrete MPR 1000 (MERV 11) Air Filter: its own listing (actual 17.5 x 17.5 x 0.75 in). The buttons above go straight to each 18x18x1 listing.

Also in 18x18x1. Filterbuy Smoke & Allergy Defense MERV 13 Air Filter (MERV 13), Filtrete MPR 1900 (MERV 13) Air Filter (MERV 13), Nordic Pure Pleated MERV 13 Air Filter (MERV 13), Filtrete MPR 1500 (MERV 12) Air Filter (MERV 12), Nordic Pure Pleated MERV 12 Air Filter (MERV 12), Filterbuy Pet & Allergy Defense MERV 11 Air Filter (MERV 11), BNX TruFilter MERV 11 Air Filter (MERV 11), Filterbuy Dust & Allergy Defense MERV 8 Air Filter (MERV 8). See every 18x18x1 filter ranked.

Airflow at 18x18x1. A 18x18x1 filter has a face of about 324 square inches (2.25 sq ft). At the roughly 300 ft/min face velocity commonly used to size 1-inch filters, that passes about 675 CFM, which suits a system of about 1.5 tons at 400 CFM per ton. If your system is larger than that, a single filter this size will run at higher velocity and resistance; homes in that position often use two returns or a deeper filter cabinet.

Where a 18x18x1 goes. A 1-inch filter of this size usually sits in a return grille or the slot beside the furnace; check it monthly and change it every one to three months.

Side by side

SpecificationFilterbuy Odor & Allergy Defense MERV 10 Air FilterFiltrete MPR 1000 (MERV 11) Air Filter
MERV rating1011
MPR (3M scale)10001000
Filters per pack4 Count2 Count
MaterialAluminum, Plastic, PolypropylenePolypropylene
Model numberAFBAD03-2PK-1E

Values are the makers' published specifications. "Not stated" means the maker doesn't publish it.

Which should you choose?

Choose the Filterbuy Odor & Allergy Defense MERV 10 Air Filter if

  • You want the least airflow resistance through the 18x18x1 for an older system

Full reference

Choose the Filtrete MPR 1000 (MERV 11) Air Filter if

  • Allergies, pets or smoke are the priority for your 18x18x1 slot

Full reference

How we research · Disclosure